Prospect Capital Cashes Out of Security Fire Systems at a 41.8% Return

Some investments are measured in decades. This one lasted about six and a half months. Earlier this week, Prospect Capital Corporation (NASDAQ: PSEC) sold its position in Security Fire Systems, a fire protection contractor it backed in May. Today, it reported a 41.8% realized gross annualized internal rate of return on the deal, with about $25 million in cash coming back. The buyer was not named. 

Prospect is a business development company, or BDC. That is a publicly traded fund that lends to and invests in private, midsize businesses, the kind too small to borrow in the bond market. BDCs pass most of their taxable income to shareholders, so investors tend to own them for the regular payouts. Prospect is run by an outside adviser, Prospect Capital Management. 

The investment began on May 4th, when Prospect and an affiliate provided a first lien senior secured term loan and preferred equity totaling about $26 million, working with Blackford Capital, a private equity firm based in Grand Rapids, Michigan. Security Fire Systems, founded in 1993, designs, installs, tests and maintains fire sprinkler and alarm systems for hotels, hospitals, schools, airports and government buildings, and holds certifications in Texas, California, Arkansas, Colorado and Oklahoma. Because an affiliate shared in that $26 million, Prospect’s own portion may have been smaller, which is worth keeping in mind when comparing it with the $25 million in exit proceeds.

The two headline numbers measure different things. A 1.2x multiple of invested capital means Prospect got back about $1.20 for every dollar it put in, counting interest income, prepayment fees, equity distributions and the final payout. The IRR turns that gain into an annual rate. A 20% gain earned in roughly half a year works out to around 40% on a yearly basis, which is why the IRR looks so much larger than the multiple. One shows how much was made, the other shows how fast. For comparison, Prospect’s exited middle-market loans have produced a gross IRR of about 14.5% over its history. The company notes that the 41.8% figure is unaudited and does not account for general expenses. 

Angel Solis, a managing director at Prospect, said the result “demonstrates our ability to generate attractive risk-adjusted returns.” 

The timing gives the news extra weight, because Prospect’s other recent results have been harder to cheer. For the quarter ended September 30th, net investment income was $76.4 million, or $0.15 a share, yet common shareholders absorbed a net loss of $53.4 million after investment write-downs. Net asset value, or NAV, the book value of the fund per share, fell to $5.36 from $5.71 three months earlier. The share count grew by about 23.5 million, or roughly 4.6%, and stock transactions alone took $0.15 off NAV per share. The monthly distribution now stands at $0.035 a share. 

The market has noticed. The stock trades around $1.26 today, about 24% of that $5.36 book value and down roughly 51% from where it began the year. 

On November 3rd, the board raised its share repurchase program by $100 million to as much as $200 million, with about $165.9 million still available as of that date. Buying back stock at a quarter of book value can lift NAV per share for the holders who remain, but it takes cash. The SFS proceeds would cover about 15% of what is left in the program. Measured against total assets of roughly $6 billion, they amount to less than half of 1%.

None of that takes away from the quality of this exit. It shows Prospect can pick a sound borrower, collect its income and get its money back quickly with a gain. What one deal cannot do is reverse a falling NAV or pay for a $200 million buyback. The clearer signal will come over the next few quarters, if exits like this begin arriving often enough, and at a large enough scale, to show up in the per-share numbers shareholders watch most closely.

Related posts

Subscribe to Newsletter

Subscribe VBNG Newsletter for news. Let's stay updated!