Bitcoin has had a rough two months. On September 21st, the world’s best known cryptocurrency traded as high as $87,374. Yesterday it touched $61,947, a drop of about 29%. In the four days before the low, Bitcoin was still trading as high as $73,923, so the final stretch alone erased about 16% of its value. By this morning, buyers had stepped back in and pushed the price back to around $64,000.
There was no single cause. Several separate pressures arrived within the same two weeks, and each one made the next a little more painful.
The first came from Washington. In the U.S. midterm elections on November 3rd, Democrats won control of both the House and the Senate. Many crypto investors had counted on a friendly Congress to pass rules that would help the industry, and the result raised doubts about that. Two days later, technology stocks sold off hard. The Nasdaq fell about 5.5%, chip stocks fell about 12%, and Bitcoin fell 5.5% in the same session.Â
That link to technology stocks matters. Many of the same investors who buy fast growing tech companies have also bought Bitcoin. When those investors get nervous, they often sell both. That is what happened on November 12th, when Jensen Huang resigned as chief executive of NVIDIA Corporation (NASDAQ: NVDA). Nvidia’s shares fell 12% at the open, and Bitcoin slipped below $72,000 as investors pulled back from anything tied to the tech trade.Â
The second pressure was inflation. October consumer prices rose 0.4% from the month before, more than economists expected. Traders now expect the Federal Reserve to raise rates over the coming year, and by more than they expected at the start of the month. When rates rise, safe investments like government bonds pay more, and an asset that pays no interest at all, like Bitcoin, looks less attractive by comparison. Long term Treasury yields climbed and the dollar strengthened, adding to the strain.Â
The third pressure came from large holders. Spot Bitcoin exchange traded funds, which let ordinary investors own Bitcoin through a brokerage account, saw about $1.91 billion leave over seven trading sessions. On a single day, $143.5 million was pulled from the iShares Bitcoin Trust run by BlackRock, Inc. (NYSE: BLK). Meanwhile, MARA Holdings, Inc. (NASDAQ: MARA), one of the largest Bitcoin miners, disclosed that it had sold 13,597 Bitcoin for about $1.1 billion after the end of September, mostly to repay loans.Â
Then came news about Strategy Inc (NASDAQ: MSTR), the largest corporate holder of Bitcoin. MSCI Inc. (NYSE: MSCI), which builds the stock indexes that many large funds copy, confirmed it will drop Strategy from its major indexes after November 30th. Funds that track those indexes will have to sell Strategy shares. Strategy is not required to sell any Bitcoin, but the decision makes it harder for the company to raise money to buy more, and Strategy has been one of the market’s most dependable buyers.Â
Fresh money was also drying up. The supply of stablecoins, the digital dollars traders keep on hand to buy crypto, shrank by $11.5 billion over 30 days. Bitcoin also traded slightly cheaper on Coinbase Global, Inc. (NASDAQ: COIN) than on overseas exchanges, a sign that U.S. buyers were holding back.
All of this set the stage for the final drop. Many traders borrow money to bet that Bitcoin will rise. When the price falls far enough, exchanges automatically sell those positions to cover the loans. Those forced sales push the price lower, which triggers more forced sales. Yesterday, about $1.96 billion in crypto positions were wiped out this way in 24 hours, including nearly $750 million in Bitcoin bets.Â
Selling of that kind tends to overshoot, which helps explain why Bitcoin bounced so quickly back to $64,000. Whether the bounce holds will likely depend on a few events ahead: Nvidia’s earnings report this week, the Federal Reserve’s decision in December, and how smoothly funds sell Strategy shares at the end of the month. Bitcoin has recovered from deep drops before, but for now, the forces that pushed it down have not gone away.
